B0.5V Bet Sco A and HD 36960 appear to have the best pedigree as B0.5V standard. Garrison94 does not list a B0.5V anchor standard. JM53 standard: eps Per, 40 Per, HR 8965 Garrison67 standard: Cl* NGC 2244 JOHN 5 - B0.5V [from Morgan65 "NGC 2244 Main Seq."] Lesh68 standard: HD 36960 - B0.5V Hiltner69 standard: bet Sco - B0.5V Walborn71 standard: HD 36960 - B0.5V Walborn72 standard: HD 36960 - B0.5V Garrison77 standard: bet Sco - B0.5V Garrison79 standard: bet Sco - B0.5V Walborn90 standard: HD 36960 - B0.5V Sota11 standard: HD 36960 - B0.5V Garcia89 lists 2 B0.5V MK standards: HD 8965 and 22951. B-V(B0.5V) = -0.295 ; EEM dereddened pri. stan. HD 36960 via Q-method B-V(B0.5V) = -0.289 ; U-B=-1.03 via trend/Q-method B-V(B0.5V) = -0.287 ; EEM dereddened N=7 HIP B0.5V stars via Q-method B-V(B0.5V) = -0.282 ; EEM dereddened pri. stan. Bet Sco A via Q-method B-V(B0.5V) = -0.28 ; Morgan53,Johnson63,JohnsonBorgman63,Johnson66,Garrison67,Fitzgerald70,Morgan71 => adopt (B-V)(B0.5V) = -0.289 [updated 2/7/2020] U-B(B0.5V) = -1.009 ; EEM dereddened primary standard Bet Sco A via Q-method U-B(B0.5V) = -1.01 ; Johnson63,Johnson66 U-B(B0.5V) = -1.02 ; JohnsonBorgman63 U-B(B0.5V) = -1.026 ; EEM dereddened N=7 B0.5V HIP stars via Q-method U-B(B0.5V) = -1.03 ; Bessell98 U-B(B0.5V) = -1.05 ; EEM dereddened pri. stan. HD 36960 via Q-method => adopt (U-B)(B0.5V) = -1.03 [updated 2/7/2020] => adopt Q(B0.5V) = -0.821 [updated 2/7/2020] => adopt (V-Ks)(B0.5V) = -0.913 => adopt (H-K)(B0.5V) = -0.063 => adopt (J-H)(B0.5V) = -0.153 => adopt (V-I)(B0.5V) = -0.338 (Bp-Rp)(B0.5V) = -0.469 ; Evans18 trend for V-I=-0.338 (g-r)(B0.5V) = -0.54 ; Covey07 interp B0V -0.59 to B1V -0.49 Teff(B0.5V) = 26378 K ; pri. stan. Bet Sco A (median Teff) Teff(B0.5V) = 26606 K ; EEM N=21 Teffs Teff(B0.5V) = 27300 K ; Bohm-Vitense81 Teff(B0.5V) = 27500 K ; Chavez95 (+200-300K) Teff(B0.5V) = 27700 K ; eclipsing binary HD 218066 (Torres10) Teff(B0.5V) = 27731 K ; U-B=-1.026 => Teff(Bessell98) Teff(B0.5V) = 28000 K ; Crowther97/Fig.3 Teff(B0.5V) = 28500 K ; Bessell98 Teff(B0.5V) = 28840 K ; Simon-Diaz17 median for B0.5V (N=5) Teff(B0.5V) = 28854 K ; pri. stan. HD 36960 Teff(B0.5V) = 29300 K ; non-standard HD 37042 (tet02 Ori B; Nieva14) Teff(B0.5V) = 29479 K ; sec. stan. HD 8965 Teff(B0.5V) = 29582 K ; Q=-0.814 => Nieva13 calibration Teff(B0.5V) = 30025 K ; Theodossiou90 (large s.dev. +-2160 K) Teff(B0.5V) = 30400 K ; non-standard HD 34816 (lam Lep; Nieva14) Teff(B0.5V) = 30700 K ; non-standard HD 37042 (tet01 Ori A; Nieva14) Teff(B0.5V) = 32060 K ; Vacca96 Teff(B0.5V) = 33412 K ; B-V=-0.287 => Teff(Bessell98) => adopt Teff(B0.5V) = 29000 K (logT = 4.462) [updated 9/20/2019] Mv(B0.5V) = -4.10 mag ; Vacca96 Mv(B0.5V) = -3.83 mag ; pri. stan. HD 36960 (see below) Mv(B0.5V) = -3.8 mag ; GrayCorbally09(halfway B0V-B1V) Mv(B0.5V) = -3.7 mag ; Russeil03 Mv(B0.5V) = -3.60 mag ; mean Mv for standards HD 36960 & bet Sco A Mv(B0.5V) = -3.6 mag ; Schmidt-Kaler82(halfway B0V-B1V) Mv(B0.5V) = -3.55 mag ; Bowen08 Mv(B0.5V) = -3.5 mag ; EEM OB trend as function of logTeff Mv(B0.5V) = -3.36 mag ; pri. stan. bet Sco A (see below) Mv(B0.5V) = -3.29 mag ; Wegner07 => adopt Mv(B0.5V) = -3.50 mag [updated 2/10/2020] => adopt M_Ks(B0.5V) = -2.587 mag = Mv - (V-Ks) = -3.50 - -0.913 [updated 12/30/2020] BCv(B0.5V) = -3.12 mag ; Vacca96 BCv(B0.5V) = -2.897 mag ; Flower96(Teff=29000K, set so BCv(5772K)=-0.085) BCv(B0.5V) = -2.850 mag ; Bertone04(ATLAS,Teff=29000K, set so BCv(5772K)=-0.085) BCv(B0.5V) = -2.841 mag ; Code76(Teff=29000K, set so BCv(5772K)=-0.085) BCv(B0.5V) = -2.828 mag ; Bessell98(ATLAS9,logg=4.0,Teff=29000K, set so BCv(5772K)=-0.085) BCv(B0.5V) = -2.825 mag ; Balona94(Teff=29000K, set so BCv(5772K)=-0.085) BCv(B0.5V) = -2.820 mag ; LanzHubeny07(Teff=29000,logg=4.0,Z/Zsun=1) BCv(B0.5V) = -2.80 mag ; Schmidt-Kaler82(halfway B0V-B1V; BCv=-2.93+0.13 offset) => adopt BCv(B0.5V) = -2.83 [updated 9/20/2019, BCv(5772K)=-0.085] logL(B0.5V) = 4.789 dex ; Vacca96 logL(B0.5V) = 4.544 dex ; pri. stan. HD 36960 (see below) logL(B0.5V) = 4.432 dex ; pri. stan. bet Sco A (see below) logL(B0.5V) = 4.428 dex ; Mv=-3.5, BCv=-2.83 mag => Mbol = -6.330 logL(B0.5V) = 4.318 dex ; logL/Teff trend for OB dwarf EBs (Torres10; Teff=29000K) logL(B0.5V) = 4.145 dex ; eclipsing binary HD 218066B (Torres10, log(age/yr)=6.6) => adopt logL(B0.5V) = 4.428 dex [updated 2/9/2020] => adopt Mbol(B0.5V) = -6.330 mag [updated 2/9/2020] Mass(B0.5V) = 11.91+-0.20 Msun ; Eclipsing binary CW Cep B (Torres10, log(age/yr)=6.6) Mass(B0.5V) = 12.81 Msun ; EEM Teff vs. Mass fit for binaries (Teff=28000K) Mass(B0.5V) = 13.05+-0.20 Msun ; Eclipsing binary CW Cep A (Torres10, log(age/yr)=6.6) Mass(B0.5V) = 13.19 Msun ; Harmanec88 Mass(B0.5V) = 13.44+-0.25 Msun ; Eclipsing binary AH Cep B (Torres10) Mass(B0.5V) = 14.8 Msun ; MIST/Choi16 solar tracks logT=4.462,logL=4.428 Mass(B0.5V) = 14.96 Msun ; EEM logL vs. Mass fit for binaries (logL=4.49) Mass(B0.5V) = 15.0+-0.7 Msun ; pri. stan. Bet Sco Aa (Catanzaro10) Mass(B0.5V) = 15.26+-0.35 Msun ; Eclipsing binary AH Cep A (Torres10) Mass(B0.5V) = 15.35 Msun ; Ekers15 ML calibration for logL=4.47 Mass(B0.5V) = 16.05 Msun ; EEM Mv vs. Mass fit for binaries (Mv=-3.7) => adopt Mass(B0.5V) = 14.8 Msun [updated 4/16/2022] Rad(B0.5V) = 6.4842 Rsun ; Teff=29000K, logL=4.428 => adopt Rad(B0.5V) = 6.484 Rsun [updated 2/9/2020] # No Standard MK43, Houk75, Keenan85, Garrison94 does not list a B0.5V standard # Primary Standard HD 144217 = Bet Sco A = Graffias *B0.5V: JM53,Bertiau58,Garrison67,Lesh68,Hiltner69(stan),Garrison77(stan),Abt81(Slettebak63),Houk88,Garrison96(for AB) B0.5IV: MK43(stan) B1V: deVauc57,Levato75 B1: Cannon The Bet Sco system consists of at least 6 stars: see schema at http://cds.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/notes/betSco.htx. Bet Sco B = HD 144218 is on a ~610 yr orbit with a=3.9" and i=87deg... according to WDS the separation was 0.8" in 1879 and was 0.3" in 2000. A is a spectroscopic binary with component "D" or "Ab" (Catanzaro10) in a 6.82 day period (Holmgren97) with delta(mag) = 1.26 (Elliot76). Holmgren97 found Aa to be T=28000+-2000K with logg=3.95+-0.33 (B0.5IV-V) and star Ab to be T=26400+-2000K with logg=4.20+-0.35 (B1.5V). Catanzaro10 find components Ab, C, and Ea to be B-type ZAMS stars, where as Aa appears to be ~1/3rd the way through its H-burning MS phase with age ~6.3 Myr. Bet Sco A was the B0.5IV standard in MK43, but became B0.5V in JM53 and has been dwarf since. Jaschek64 lists B0.5IV,B0.5V,B0V,B1V. One of three B0.5Vs in Garrison96's list "The Brighest Stars" (with theta Car and eta Ori AB). Mermilliod91 lists V=2.559+-0.049, U-B=-0.857+-0.014, B-V=-0.073+-0.008. => updated Q-method (10/9/2011) => (B-V)o=-0.282, (U-B)o=-1.009, E(B-V)=0.209, Av=0.676. VanLeeuwen07 reports plx = 8.19+-1.17 mas => 122+-18 pc. Catanzaro10 splits the photometry for the components: V(Aa)=2.62, V(Ab)=3.88, V(C)=4.52, V(Ea)=6.60. Catanzaro estimates Av=0.55+-0.03, Mv(Aa)=-3.92+-0.05, BC=-2.7+-0.2, Mbol= -6.6+-0.2, logL=4.5+-0.1, R/Rsun=6.3+-0.5, M=15.0+-0.7 Msun. Adopting Catanzaro10's Av and Vmag, and adopting BCv=-2.83, I estimate: Mv = -3.36, mbol = -0.76, Mbol = -6.19, logL=4.38. Hauck97 photometry for Beta Sco AB dereddened using Castelli91: (b-y)o=-0.118, co=-0.011, E(b-y)=0.124, Av=0.543. Teffs: 25274K(EEM,Hauck97 photometry=>Napiwotzki93 calibration), 25793K(EEM,Hauck97 photometry=>Balona94 calibration), 26378K(EEM, Hauck97 beta photometry=>BalonaShobbrook84 calibration), 26876K(U-Bo=>Bessell98), 30540+-2080K(Zorec09) => median Teff = 26378K. HD 36960 = HR 1887 = BD-06_1234 *B0.5V: Slettebak63,Walborn71(stan),Walborn72,Abt77,Jaschek78(Lesh68),Walborn90(stan),Sota11(stan) B0IV: Berger68 B0Vp: Morgan55 B1/2Ib/II: Houk99 No Mermilliod91 UBV data, however Stromgren photometry is available. Johnson66 lists V=4.79, B-V=-0.25, U-B=-1.02 => updated Q-method calibration (10/9/2011) => (B-V)o = -0.296, (U-B)o = -1.053, E(B-V) = 0.046, Av=0.148. Cousins71 lists B-V=-0.245, U-B = -1.01 => revised Q-method (10/9/2011) => (B-V)o = -0.294, (U-B)o = -1.045, E(B-V) = 0.049, Av=0.156. Hauck97 photometry dereddened following Castelli91: (b-y)o=-0.111, co=-0.057, E(b-y)=0.005, Av=0.021 (i.e. essentially unreddened). Has B1V companion HR 1886 (= HD 36959) 36" away. B0.5V standard in all Walborn studies including Sota11. VanLeeuwen07 reports plx =2.02+-0.31 mas => 495+-78 pc. Hence, Mv = -3.83+-0.33, logL = 4.54+-0.13 dex. Teffs: 27000K(Koleva12), 27411K(EEM,Hauck97 photometry=>Balona94 calibration), 27866K(EEM,Hauck97 photometry=>Napiwotzki93 calibration), 28271K(EEM,Hauck97 beta photometry=>BalonaShobbrook84 calibration), 28788K(U-Bo=>Bessell98), 28920K(Cunha94), 29000+-300K(Nieva12), 29500K(Kaufer94), 29800K(Kilian94), 29960K(Gies92) => median Teff = 28854K. logg=4.10(Koleva12), 4.10+-0.07(Nieva12), 4.15(Kilian94), 4.25(Kaufer94), 4.30(Gies92), 4.33(Cunha94). # Secondary Standards HD 8965 = ALS 6596 = MCW 69 (J0129+6015) *B0.5V: JM53,Jaschek64(all),Jaschek78(Morgan55),Garcia89 B0V: Bidelman43 B1V: McCuskey74 B5: Cannon Rarely used a standard in the past few decades. VanLeeuwen07 plx = -0.22+-0.65 mas. No sign of cluster on DSS, no cluster/association membership in SIMBAD references, and it does not share motion with other nearby hot stars -- apparently it is an isolated early B-type star (so I can't find a useful distance estimate). No published Teffs as of Nov 2012. Hauck97 photometry dereddened following Castelli91: (b-y)o=-0.127, co=-0.054, E(b-y)=0.229, Av=1.005 mag. Mermilliod91 lists: V=7.276+-0.004, B-V=0.028+-0.005, U-B=-0.820+-0.101 (large errors). Q-method (11/26/2012) on M91 photometry: (B-V)o = -0.296, (U-B)o = -1.054, E(B-V)=0.324, Av=1.046. Teffs: 28131K(EEM, Hauck97 beta photometry => BalonaShobbrook84 calibration), 29313K(U-Bo=>Bessell98), 29645K(EEM, Hauck97 photometry=>Napiwotzki93 calibration), 30094K(EEM,Hauck97 photometry => Balona94 calibration) => median Teff = 29479K. # Deprecated Standards HD 46106 = HIP 31106 = Cl* NGC 2244 JOHN 5 (J0631+0501) *B0V: Morgan65,Garrison67(stan),Abt68,Walborn71 B0.2V: Massey95,Wolff07 B0.5V: Morgan53,Johnson62 B1V: JM53 B8: Cannon B1III: Voroshilov85 Jaschek64 shows slew of types from O9.5V to B1V. Abt68 uses as B0V standard. Garrison67 adopts "NGC 2244 Main Sequence" from Morgan65 for B0-B2V standards, including Johnson #5, which includes HD 46106 as "B0V". Too much disagreement to consider a useful standard. Mermilliod91 lists V=7.927+-0.012, BV=0.145+-0.006, U-B=-0.755+-0.011 => revised Q-method (10/8/2011) => (B-V)o = -0.303, (U-B)o = -1.077, E(B-V)=0.448, Av=1.449 mag. HD 201795 *B0.7V: Walborn71(stan) B1V: Jaschek64(all),Jaschek78(Morgan53) B3: Cannon HD 22951 = 40 Per = omi Per = HR 1123 *B0.7V: Walborn72 B0.5V: JM53,Jaschek64(all),Jaschek78(Murphy69),Garcia89 B2: Cannon B1IV: Lesh68 B1.5IV: Abt83 B0V: Berger55 Some scatter in the published values. I adopt Walborn's value as he was placing the O/B stars on a denser grid of standards. HD 24760 = eps Per = 45 Per = ALS 7825 *B0.5III: Lesh68,Garcia89,MK78 B0.5V: JM53,Jaschek64(most),Jaschek78(Murphy69) B0III: Berger62 B1.5III: Abt83 B1: Cannon Morgan switched from B0.5V (JM53) to B0.5III (MK78). # Other Stars tet Car = theta Car = *B0.2Vp: AbtMorgan72,Walborn76 B0.5Vp: Hiltner69,Kennedy83,Garrison96 B0V: Hoffleit56,Whiteoak61,Jaschek78 B0: Cannon O9.5V: deVauc57 Jaschek64 lists O9.5V, B0V, B0Vp. Houk75 lists Hiltner69 B0.5Vp. Never proposed as a standard, and probably shouldn't be. Garrison96 comments "Nitrogen enhanced". This appears to be a blue straggler in the ~50 Myr-old cluster IC 2602. SB1 period 2.2 days, probably underwent mass transfer from the companion. Lesh68 classifies 5 stars as B0.5V or variant: HD 24131, 35411, 36960, 144217, & 198781. Garrison96 listed 3 B0.5V (or variant) stars in their table "The Brightest Stars": eta Ori AB, the Car, and bet Sco AB.